The French National Frequency Agency (ANFR) has denied pressure group Phonegate Alert’s request for 30 reports on non-compliant Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) tests of mobile phones and connected devices. The agency stated that reports issued as part of administrative sanction procedures cannot be disclosed without manufacturer consent. The association argues that ANFR’s stance is legally unfounded and contradicts prior decisions by the Commission for Access to Administrative Documents (CADA). The CADA considers such reports administrative documents that must be communicated when public health and environmental information is concerned.
Dr. Marc Arazi, president of Phonegate Alert, stressed the importance of transparency. He stated that public health concerns should take precedence over private interests when access to SAR data is restricted.
Major manufacturers are implicated
The SAR reports withheld involve major companies including Samsung, Apple, Motorola, Xiaomi, and Nokia. According to ANFR, these manufacturers have refused authorization for the release of their respective reports. This refusal limits public access to data on potential overexposure to mobile phone and connected device waves.
Phonegate Alert refers case to CADA
In response, Phonegate Alert has formally referred the matter to the CADA. The association seeks an official opinion to affirm the public’s right to full information on non-compliant SAR test reports.
Association escalates to Parliament and health authorities
The group also plans to inform French Parliament and health authorities. The organization argues that restricting access undermines environmental transparency and public health precautions.
Dr. Arazi emphasized the importance of trust, stating that public confidence relies on the transparency of both authorities and manufacturers. Citizens, he notes, have the right to complete information regarding the risks associated with waves from mobile phones and connected devices.
Health transparency is a public priority
The ongoing dispute highlights a broader debate on public health, environmental safety, and corporate accountability. Access to SAR data is increasingly critical as mobile phone usage and connected device proliferation continue to rise.
Market
Trade-in
Repair
Refurbishing
